Question
25 Nov 2020
- English (UK)
- English (US)
-
Japanese
-
Korean
Question about Japanese
Why do you write "ha" in hiragana, for "wa"?
Why do you write "ha" in hiragana, for "wa"?
Answers
Read more comments
- Spanish (Mexico)
- Spanish (Spain)
It depends on what are you talking about. Wa is used as Wa in common words;
わたし *私* (I)
You use the wa in words.
But, the particle Ha, is ha and not wa. It's an exception.
私はアメリカ人です。
I'm American.
は is, in fact, は when it's a particle. Not わ, though it's read as WA.
わ is わ in words. You can't say Hatashi, it's Watashi.
"Why????" It's a cultural reason. The government decided to make this rule for the Japanese language.
- Japanese
In "Old Kanazukai", "ha" other than the beginning of the word was pronounced "wa". When it became "new Kanazukai", I decided to write "wa" other than the particle as "wa" as it sounds, but I found that it was a particle only when it was the particle "ha". For the sake of simplicity, it was left with the notation "ha (wa)".
- Japanese
The characters which Japanese people used has been changing throughout the history. Originally, they had no characters to signify their language. So they adopted Chinese characters to make it sound as the pronunciation of their speech. This became Kanji. Kan(漢) is the name of a Chinese nation back then.
Since then they had developped Kanji to make it to their own styles, which created Hiragana or Katakana. But basically they kept doing the same things; "Altering characters to apply them to the same sounds."
亜→あ→ア
This is mainly for practical use when it comes to be used by many people in middle ages. Because using Kanji every time is so hassling. And this time around (maybe the middle of Edo era)was when it was decided that the sound "wa" should be noted as は(even though は itself was pronounced as "ha".) And the "wa" sound lying in the head of words was excluded from this rule, In which case わ was used.
This is the reason to your question, and in fact, it came from the process of transition of writing system; how to signify the sounds/syllable.
[pronunciation]
はHa/Wa
わWa
[usage in a sentence①]
わたしは(This was adopted as correct)
わたしわ(☓Not like this)
[usage in a sentence②]
かはりに(This was adopted as correct)
かわりに(☓Not like this)
But this was confusing because there's two letters to signify one sound "wa". And the rule was changed even after this period(at the reformation of education disipline in Meiji era). It was meant to steamline how to switch the two characters は&わ.
The criteria "basically" made each characters loyal to the corresponding syllable. わ for "wa"sound, and は for "ha"sound.
[usage in a sentence③]
かわりに(This time, This is adopted as correct )
かはりに(☓this was retracted.)
But beforementioned [the usage in a sentence①] rule was kept validated after this reformation. (As the two people answered already, it is applied to only when it is "wa" particle.)
That's why we are still using a bit confusing system of using two letters for one sound.
Highly-rated answerer
- English (UK)
- English (US)
@afiri107mk OHHHHHH!!! ARIGATOU!!!! I get it now, thank you for helping me understand!
- Japanese
@Yotaver
That's great. And very glad to help.
Highly-rated answerer

[News] Hey you! The one learning a language!
Do you know how to improve the way you study a language❓ All you need to do is write a diary in the language you are learning!
With HiNative, you can have a native speaker correct your diary every day✍️✨
With HiNative, you can have a native speaker correct your diary every day✍️✨
Sign up
Newest Questions
- Is it weird to name “Ian” for a girl? I have asked some friends and they said “Ian” is a male nam...
- The police officer managed to track down the perp in Shinjuku city. Is this sentence correct?
- We worked hard around the clock to win over them. Is this sentence correct?
- He's eaten up all of his money. Is this sentence correct?
- Hello, could someone help me with my English pronunciation and speaking skills? 😄
Topic Questions
- If something is consequent of an event does it mean that it is an inevitable result of the event?
- I don’t say that my all life is at my best. However I think I’m going through many happy time. ...
- i was tired im school is this sentence natural?
- When I want to say LITERALLY in the true meaning, not super or very (I mean not as a slang), how ...
- “A coffee shop I have passed by a few times but not gone. “ Is this sentence OK? Sounds natural?...
Recommended Questions